hope | Everybody Loves A Homerotic Bond In The Trenches

Skip to Main Content

Current Mood: thoughtful
Current Music: perhaps, perhaps, perhaps - doris day

Entry tags:

Everybody Loves A Homerotic Bond In The Trenches

There's been a lot of speculation around about John's relationship to Ellen and Jo; namely, a lot of people are thinking that Jo is John's illegitimate daughter. I have to admit I don't particularly agree with that interpretation, for a number of reasons.

- Timing. Jo is what, no younger than about 19? That would mean that about three, four years after Mary's death John would be sexing Ellen. I kind of have mixed views about how much sexing John would have done after Mary's death, even *that* long after, though I'm not ruling it out entirely. However, this would make Jo considerably younger than Dean, and... not sure if they'd do that. It depends on where the creators take that 'relationship'.

- My impression of the Winchester family is that it's a pretty self-contained bastion. Its integrity is based on its hermetic nature - it's All About Them. their vigilante logic is all based on the family, not the greater good, John is clearly still obsessed with his wife 20 years after her death, etc etc. In other words, I'm not sure that the show would undermine the construction of their family by introducing illegitimate children (be they demonspawn!Sam or Jo) etc - i.e. Winchesters who aren't entirely Winchesters. Because that's what the essence of the show is about. People who are Entirely Winchesters. (Then again, I wouldn't put it past Kripke & co to undermine it deliberately to fuck things up. But i think it's more likely that they'd introduce that *potential*, make the characters deal with it, the reveal that it isn't true (demons lie/manipulate/etc) - Think Veronica & Keith Mars and the paternity test, hey?)

- The construction of Ellen and Jo as parallell to John and Dean. Ellen and John are reflections of each other (whilst maintaining their own characterisation, OMG SHOW I LOVE YOU), they're not complementary components. Mary was John's complementary component, Dean is Sam's (Dean and Sam are not reflections of each other).

WHICH LEADS TO MY SUBJECT LINE. Ellen's complementary component. (and here's where my thoughts go all meandering...)

Jo is very fair. This is another thing that makes me think she's not John's child; Ellen isn't that fair herself. Sure, if Mary Winchester had impregnated Ellen I could see Jo being the result, but John? even with blonde!mary, his children are reasonably dark (you're dark) in colouring (though, jo does have awesome dark eyes).

So, that made me think that heh, Jo's father was probably blond. So, John and Ellen both had blond(e) spouses. Further complementary + reflection stuff, there. And, um, Jo's father was also a hunter, and is also dead.

Then my brain got all excited. When did John meet/know Ellen? was it before or after her husband died? Is it quite possible that - gasp - John hunted with Ellen's husband? aka the blond, male, Mary-reflection? Then I got all excited in my pants, so to speak. Ellen's family is a varied reflection of the Winchesters, with genders inverted. Maybe adultery isn't your thing, but the thought of John off hunting and fucking with a male version of Mary takes me to a very happy place. Brothers/lovers in arms (a la wincest, even).

Also, John angst, because of course Jo's father DIES at some point. And maybe, she speculated with further glee into the 'verse she's entirely creating out of thin air, MAYBE Mr.Ellen's death is in direct relation to John (hah, Caleb, Jim, etc...), maybe John feels responsible, maybe that's the source of his self-enforced alienation from Ellen. MAYBE it was one big love triangle thing. MAYBE.

And man, I want to write that whole damn fic, now. Epicly so. Only, we've had what - ONE episode with Ellen's family? No doubt I would be jossed before the end of the season. Still, see above comment about being happy in my pants.

As a kind of unrelated aside, all the talk and excitement over the Dean/Ellen pairing makes me cackle with glee, too. Because as I said, Ellen is John's counterpart. So to me, these people are getting all squeeful about John/Dean by proxy.

Also, on the flipside of that coin, how do people feel about Ellen/Jo?

Threaded | Top-Level Comments Only

Sure, if Mary Winchester had impregnated Ellen I could see Jo being the result
exactly :D

hm. proxy. proxxxy.

i'm kinda meh on the whole dean/ellen, ellen/jo front. i'd read it but it doesnt quite do it for me, i guess.

i love th emeta in this fandom. its so very smart. it makes me feel smart by comparison.

Ellen's family is a varied reflection of the Winchesters, with genders inverted. Maybe adultery isn't your thing, but the thought of John off hunting and fucking with a male version of Mary takes me to a very happy place...

MAYBE Mr.Ellen's death is in direct relation to John (hah, Caleb, Jim, etc...), maybe John feels responsible, maybe that's the source of his self-enforced alienation from Ellen...

Happy. In. My. Pants.

Yeah.

I like proxxxy.

Also, fempreg. *g*

Yea verily, I'm not all that pinged by het narratives, and haven't seen enough of Ellen and Jo to see much subtext between them.

yay meta :)

I am friending you now, so that we can more conveniently share our Happiness In Pants in future. :)

Oh, I am SO tempted to write this. NO TIME!

I'm just curious.. you think that heterosexual sex - John with another woman, invalidates his commitment to Mary (it's something you can't see him doing.) But that homosexual sex does not? (John/Mr. Ellen makes you happy in your pants.)

I'm not challenging you, I have no challenging tone. I'm just curious. :)

(Dean and Sam are not reflections of each other).

I think they very much are! That they are, in a way, shadow-images of each other. The other's "own unsuspected self."

I was actually thinking briefly about John/Mr. Ellen or John/Ellen/Mr. Ellen or a possible love triangle thing just this very day. Quelle chance. Please write eeet.

all the talk and excitement over the Dean/Ellen pairing

There is talk and excitement? How joyful. I like the pairing. beeeecause.
these people are getting all squeeful about John/Dean by proxy.

yes. :)

how do people feel about Ellen/Jo?

Eh. Lukewarm. I think, as a parent and a woman and a daughter, that one cuts a little too close to home. I'd give it a go. If it's well-written, I'll pretty much give almost anything a go.

I do agree with you that making the Winchesters not be Winchesters would undermine the strength of the show. Doesn't mean it won't happen, but..

fempreg!

Yay!! We'll be happy, our pants'll be happy, and all shall be right with the world. Amen.

OMG, I know! Imagine the possibilities based on THE PRETTY factor alone. O_O

Although the thought of John impregnating a very young Ellen.. she'd be just about twenty years younger than him, right? And maybe she hadn't married Mr. Ellen yet, and there was sexual tension between all of them, and John couldn't very well fuck another man, so he staggers off with Ellen and there was straddling and there was drunken roughridin and oops. ohshitOOPS. And Ellen never was quite sure which one her baby's daddy was.

That makes me squish.

Just as a thing, going by Jo's diary (from what Mary's put on the relevant site), she's supposed to be 21, I believe.

Oooer. I think that one kinda makes ME squish, too!!

Why do you think Ellen would be so much younger? What do you estimate John's age at? Sure, she doesn't *look* like she's in her late 50s or whatever, but neither does JDM, hah.

I'm just curious.. you think that heterosexual sex - John with another woman, invalidates his commitment to Mary (it's something you can't see him doing.) But that homosexual sex does not? (John/Mr. Ellen makes you happy in your pants.)

Nah, I agree, this is an interesting point. Derry and I get into this on occassion. Like, Derry is obviously a slobbering Johnslash freak, but strongly believes John would be celibate following Mary's death.

For me, it's not so much a difference between gay and het relationships, it's a difference between fantext and canon.

Like, I have reservations with regards to how much John would have been interested in romantic relationships post-Mary in the canon, but this doesn't stop me from reading and writing stories where John gets laid by people who are male or female.

I don't know, it's kind of touchy. But I guess somewhere in there is my division between canon and fanon, not so much where I think that fanfiction is WRONG because that would NEVER happen in canon, and i'm just titilated by the sex in it, but more that... fanfic is an extrapolation of canon. At the start of this post where I talk about the possibility of John sexing Ellen, I'm talking more about where I speculate the show will take that.

The extension of John's characterisation in fanon obviously posits it as much more likely. I really don't think that the show will give John a gay history with Ellen's deceased husband, but I'm already pseudo-ficcing away on that potential element.

Essentially, I love John, and love getting him laid, and don't see that as OOC, but I have doubts as to how much sex he'll ever get in canon.

Wow, that was all over the place!

What do you estimate John's age at?

old enough to go to Nam. I imagine him somewhere around thirty in the Pilot. So.. yeah, in his mid fifties or thereabouts.

And I was just going by looks for Ellen. Without any canon to place her age -- I figured somewhere between forty and forty-five. And Jo's like, 21?

Or, heck. It's just possible I like the thought of 35-ish-year-old John fucking a girl just this side of jailbait despite all of his Mary-angst and chivalric reservations very hot.

I wouldn't rule it out.

Because John will do what he thinks is right, but he's not a gentleman, you know? I really love that about him.

Hell yes! I keep on meaning to make a post about that, how there's a kind of anti-misogyny reading in there, somewhere... He's not about to treat anyone different just because they're a GIRL. Like his equal treatment of the vampires as all monsters in DMB.

Yep, she's 21, and I think -- I'd have to double-check this, but going on memory -- there's a reference to 'Uncle John' working a case while Ellen's partner is still alive. Lemme look --- yep, John was a regular at the roadhouse over a year before Jo's dad died.

See me keymash, now. I am going to be looking at the hunters' blogs soon, methinks. THESIS NOW.

'Anti-misogyny' being another way of saying, gee, I don't know...

fem·i·nism (fĕm'ə-nĭz'əm)
n.

1. Belief in the social, political, and economic equality of the sexes. (emphasis mine)

yes, i know, we've had this discussion before. i used that term because not everyone has that in-built dictionary wherein feminism equates equality, as opposed to pro-women.

That entry's one of the ones I mentioned to you soon after the DVDs came out -- it went deleted/private a week after the journal went 'live'. See, Jo's tetchy with her journal! I am a sekrit hottie barmaid!!1

GOOD THING I'M MAKING YOU SAVE EVERYTHING!

I know, and I knee-jerk in my response because I want to remind all the lovely folk who read your journal that the textbook definition of feminism isn't actually 'broiled testicles for breakfast every morning and a lampshade made of manskin'.

And that the textbook definition of meta is "self-referential; referring to itself or its characteristics"? Or, you know, a "dyke" is "an embankment for controlling or holding back the waters of the sea or a river"?

or, yaknow, as you're fond of reminding me - texts don't exist in a vacuum. neither does terminology.

Or, you know, a "dyke" is "an embankment for controlling or holding back the waters of the sea or a river"?

You don't seriously think I'm going to engage in a discussion where you compare the fact that you don't want to use feminism as a synonym for anti-misogynist to the fact that dyke has come to have a slang meaning completely unconnected to its original definition, do you? Yes, the perception of what 'feminism' means has shifted due to various backlashes, splinterings and misunderstandings, but let's not throw the baby out with the damn bathwater.

Threaded | Top-Level Comments Only

Page 1 of 3

«

1
2
3

»